Most agencies show up with a proposal. We show up with questions.

On November 11, I sat down with Gerardo at Window World Sarasota for 95 minutes. No pitch deck. No package pricing. Just a screen share, a spreadsheet, and a commitment to understand what is actually happening before recommending anything.

That is the audit-first rule at Rohde Marketing. We look at the full tech stack, the website, past ad history, SEO data, and the Google Business Profile before we prescribe a single thing. Here is what we found.

253 Blog Articles. 6 Earning Any Traffic at All.

Window World Sarasota has 127 blog articles on their site. Fort Myers has 126. When we pulled the data, 126 of those articles had a 99% content overlap between the two locations. Same topics, nearly word-for-word copy, split across two domains.

Of all 253 articles, only 6 earn any Google impressions at all.

One article, a DP glass ratings guide, drives 7,637 impressions and 74 clicks on its own. That single piece of content equals 14% of Sarasota’s entire organic click volume. One article out of 127 is carrying the whole site.

Then we checked the sitemap. It lists 1 of the 127 Sarasota articles and 0 of the 126 Fort Myers articles. Google is not being told these pages exist. That is not a content problem. That is a technical problem, and it has a fix.

The GBP Is Actually Good. The Tracking Is Not.

This is worth saying clearly because a lot of audits turn into a list of everything wrong. The Window World GBP is well built. Right categories, 66 service items listed, 194 out of 198 unique photos, and photos uploaded as recently as October 15. Gerardo’s team has been doing the work. The issue is not neglect. The posts are syndicated across locations rather than written for Sarasota specifically, and that is an easy correction.

The tracking problem is a bigger issue. Two systems are counting the same quote form submissions and they disagree by 2.5 times. Sarasota shows either 102 leads or 40 leads depending on which platform you look at. Fort Myers shows either 106 or 46. The difference matters because the same 30 appointments reads as either a 14% booking rate or a 35% booking rate depending on the number you trust.

When you are making decisions about ad spend and lead targets, that gap is not acceptable. My rule on this is simple: every client-facing claim has to trace back to a platform API, not a proxy or an inference. We will fix the tracking before we run a single dollar in paid ads.

What the Business Context Tells Us About the Strategy

Gerardo’s numbers matter here because they shape every decision. The average ticket is $14,000. Gross margin runs around 37 to 38%. The target is roughly 1,800 leads per year, and Sarasota is currently sitting at 4% market share against an 8% goal.

Corporate has blocked a second franchise until certain thresholds are hit. There is a no-discounting rule, which is a hard brand constraint. And there is a $7,500 minimum financed amount that has never appeared anywhere in the marketing, which is a real differentiator being left on the table.

One more thing we identified during the audit: comfort and heat gain as a core messaging angle. Windows in Southwest Florida are not just about curb appeal. They are about keeping your house livable in August. That angle had never been used before we flagged it.

What Comes Next

Here is the short list of what the audit surfaced before we wrote a single recommendation:

None of this is guesswork. It all came out of one honest audit before we touched a single ad.

If you want to know what is actually working in your marketing before you spend another dollar, that is exactly what we do. Book a free strategy call with Matt and we will start there.